NOT UNIFORM. Unfortunately, FET behavior is anything but uniform. This statement is true even for FETs of the same brand and batch.
Characteristics that set the bias can differ by five to one! Meanwhile, the device still remains in spec.
Tubes and bipolar transistors are far more predictable. Manufacturers allow these FET specs to vary widely...
In fairness, specs of some FETs are tighter than for other FETs.
WHY DO WE CARE ABOUT SPEC SPREAD? If spec spread affects the device bias, then
the preamplifier might distort, or might not work. The source resistor sets the DC bias point (Vs). The input signal is a sine wave. This sine wave rises above and falls below the the bias point. Now let's consider the output at the device drain. Under no-signal (quiescent) conditions, we should find a DC voltage Vd between the drain and ground. This is the quiescent point (Q-point). The Q-point also depends on the DC bias setting. For example, when source bias rises, so does the drain Q-point.
Let's run a signal through the amplifier: The highest peak of the output wave can rise almost to the power voltage (Vdd). The lowest peak can fall almost to the device's source voltage peak. (In our case, excursions of Source Voltage Vs run a little above ground.) We want to set the bias point (Vd) about halfway between Vdd and average Vs. We make the setting under no-signal conditions. With a correct setting, we can amplify the signal a lot before the amplifier clips.
- Suppose that the bias point (Vd) is close to the top power rail. Then the amplifier might clip the top of the
waveform.
- Suppose that Vd is close to Source Voltage Vs. Then the amplifier might clip the bottom of the waveform.
- Suppose that Vd ("q-point") is halfway between the top power rail and Vs. Then we achieve ideal performance.
With spec spread, we can't say for sure where our bias point will be. We also don't know for sure if our design will clip
or not. Maybe the amplifier works, but we must avoid clipping by turning it down low. Obviously, spec spread affects the
predictability and quality of our project.
COPE BY TESTING. The preamp uses a typical MPF102 JFET. In this circuit, some MPF102s perform well. Yet others
might not operate at all. One way to cope with this problem is to hand-pick your JFETs. Here's how: Buy at least half a dozen FETs.
Check them in the circuit nearby.
For such tests, I recommend a plugboard. In twenty minutes, you can easily test several FETs and
weed out troublesome ones. Set aside devices that don't bias correctly. For example...
Set Device Aside
|
Vd Too High
|
Vd Too Low
|
Vd = 8.24
|
Vs = 1.74
|
Vd = 1.86
|
Vs = 1.53
|
Keep Device
|
Vd is 88% Perfect!
|
Vd is 99% Perfect!
|
Vd = 4.64
|
Vs = 1.59
|
Vd = 5.14
|
Vs = 1.40
|
|
Test of different JFETs
|
\
|
2N3819
|
MPF102
|
Test
|
Vd
|
Vs
|
Vd
|
Vs
|
01
|
4.24
|
1.74
|
4.86
|
1.53
|
02
|
4.84
|
1.52
|
5.38
|
1.33
|
03
|
4.06
|
1.81
|
5.12
|
1.43
|
04
|
4.20
|
1.75
|
4.83
|
1.54
|
05
|
4.27
|
1.73
|
4.49
|
1.66
|
06
|
5.38
|
1.32
|
5.53
|
1.28
|
07
|
4.75
|
1.55
|
5.26
|
1.38
|
08
|
4.55
|
1.63
|
4.74
|
1.57
|
09
|
4.61
|
1.61
|
4.85
|
1.53
|
10
|
4.64
|
1.59
|
5.14
|
1.40
|
11
|
5.00
|
1.46
|
4.33
|
1.72
|
KEY
- Vd = Drain voltage (between drain & ground)
- Vs = Source voltage (between source & ground)
|
Version of preamp to test spec spread
|